Operation Alsos

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Operation Alsos was an effort at the end of World War II by the Allies (principally Britain and the United States), branched off from the Manhattan Project, to investigate the German nuclear energy project, seize German nuclear resources, materials and personnel to further American research and to prevent their capture by the Soviets, and to discern how far the Germans had gone towards creating an atomic bomb. The personnel of the project followed close behind the front lines, first into Italy, and then into France and Germany, searching for personnel, records, material, and sites involved.

Alsos is sometimes mistakenly written ALSOS by sources including the U.S. Army, perhaps because it does not look like a usual English word and is thus falsely assumed to be an acronym. In fact, Alsos is Greek for "grove", and so this designation is a play on the name of Major General Leslie M. Groves, the military director of the Manhattan Engineering District (the Manhattan Project), the Allied wartime effort to develop an atomic bomb (which itself was sparked out of fears of a German weapon). Groves was the major impetus behind the project, in part because of his desire to make sure that German technology and personnel did not fall into Soviet hands, so as to prolong the anticipated American monopoly on nuclear weapons as long as possible.

Samuel Goudsmit was the technical/scientific leader of Alsos, and Lt. Col. Boris Pash, a former Manhattan Project security officer, was its military leader. Major League baseball player, attorney, and linguist, Moe Berg contributed in various phases.

The project managed to find and remove many of the German research effort's personnel and a substantial portion of the surviving records and equipment. Most of the senior research personnel (including Werner Heisenberg, Otto Hahn, and Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker) were sequestered at Farm Hall in England for several months, as part of Operation Epsilon. Their discussions were secretly recorded, and transcripts of those tapes have been released.

In the end, Operation Alsos concluded that the Allies had surpassed the entire German atomic bomb effort by 1942. Compared to the Manhattan Project, one of the largest scientific endeavors of all time, the German project was considerably underfunded and understaffed, and it is questionable whether Germany would have had the resources or concentrated research attention which the Allies used to produce such a weapon. Some postwar researchers deduced that this was in part the result of deliberate acts by Heisenberg to prevent the development of an atomic bomb.

Goudsmit, in a monograph published two years after the end of the war, further concluded that a principal reason for the failure of the German project was that science could not flourish under totalitarianism — an argument many think adequately rebutted by German advances in other realms, such as the world's first operational jet fighter (Messerschmitt Me 262) and the first ballistic missile (V-2), as well as the Soviet Union's development of a nuclear weapon by 1949. The Soviets, however, benefited from Stalin's extensive spy networks, which included at least two well-informed scientists at Los Alamos, Klaus Fuchs and Theodore Hall. Both worked to prevent the United States from holding a nuclear monopoly over the world.

Goudsmit is said to have made the statement regarding totalitarianism under "instructions" to support and clear Heisenberg, who personified the new pro-western German scientific order. After Heisenberg's death Goudsmit revised his statement, claiming that Heisenberg was always working to finish off what he has started, which contrasts with the impression the German project came to a halt through politics. Other German scientists who worked with Heisenberg supported this view and denied Heisenberg's claims.

[edit] See also

• Operation Alsos included Operation Big and Operation Harborage.
• Similar (but separate) attempts to remove German technical information and personnel after the war were Operation Paperclip (Overcast) (rocketry) and TICOM (cryptography).
• Annotated bibliography of the Alsos missions from the Alsos Digital Library for Nuclear Issues

[edit] Further reading

• Jeremy Bernstein and David Cassidy, Hitler's Uranium Club: The Secret Recordings at Farm Hall, 2001.
• Charles Frank, ed. Operation Epsilon: the Farm Hall transcripts, 1993.
• David Irving, Virus House, 1967. (see Irving link for discussion of Irving's reliability as an historian).
• Samuel Goudsmit, Alsos: the failure of German science, 1947.
• Mahoney, Leo J. A History of the War Department Scientific Intelligence Mission (ALSOS), 1943 – 1945. [Ph.D. Dissertation, Kent State University, 1981]
• Pash, Boris. The Alsos Mission. New York: Charter Books, 1969.
• Thomas Powers, Heisenberg's War: The Secret History of the German Bomb, 2000. Powers makes an inferential case that the German effort was, essentially, sabotaged by scientific foot-dragging, perhaps especially by Heisenberg.
• Paul Lawrence Rose, Heisenberg and the Nazi Atomic Bomb Project: A Study in German Culture (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998), ISBN 0-529-21977-8.
• Mark Walker, German National Socialism and the quest for nuclear power, 1939 – 1949, 1990.